5 Surprising Statistics About Top Sellers

Several weeks ago I keynoted an actuarial conference at one of the Big 4 accounting firms. These really smart people spend their days analyzing data and calculating risk. 

Just the thought of “selling” makes most actuaries cringe. They view people who do it as slimy, manipulative and disgusting—not at all like them. Yet their leadership team very wisely realized that future growth depended on them acquiring these skills.

How was I going to change the actuaries’ perception of sales?

I quickly realized that I needed data from reliable resources to open their mind to new ways of thinking. What I found surprised me – yet it rang so true. Sales Rep Surprised by Sales Research Results

What personality types do the best in sales?

One of my favorite researchers is Steve W. Martin, a professor at the USC Marshall School of Business and author of Heavy Hitter Sales Psychology. He wanted to find out how top sellers differed from average or struggling reps. 

To do that, he administered personality tests to one thousand B2B salespeople who worked at some of the world’s leading companies. Here's what his research showed along with a few of my own thoughts.

Sales Research on Top Sellers:

  • 91% of top sellers had medium to high scores of modesty and humility.
    What? Winning salespeople aren't totally egotistical? No. They don't have to be the center of attention. They don't need to flaunt their wins. Instead, they want their customers to take the credit for making wise decisions. And they truly value the support they get from their own colleagues along the way. 
  • 85% of top sellers were highly conscientious.
    Highly conscientious. Not just average. Essentially, that means that don't leave anything to chance. They research, study and think about how they can help their customers make a good business decision. They keep things moving, involving the right people at the right time. They're reliable hard workers. 
  • 82% of top sellers scored extremely high curiosity levels.
    Extremely curious. That's fascinating. Top sellers want to learn more—about their customers, market, products, value propositions, triggering events, the buying process and the individuals they deal with. With a deep hunger for knowledge and information, they ask more and better questions. 
  • Top sellers were 30% less gregarious than average sellers.
    Contrary to popular opinion, being super friendly is not the key to sales success. Extroversion does not trump introversion. Sellers who are overly focused on building deep personal relationships have a harder time challenging their customer's thinking and getting them to move off the status quo. They don't want to rock the proverbial boat.
  • 84% of top sellers scored very high in achievement orientation.
    Not just high—very high. That means they have a goal in mind and that they're damned sure going to do everything in their power to achieve it. Top sellers keep track of progress and are brutally honest with how things are going. They seek out potential obstacles so they can eliminate/minimize them before they occur. They strategize, coming up with Plans A, B and even C. They never hope for success, they create it. 

This is NOT the image that most people have of salespeople. Yet it is certainly my own experience working with thousands of sellers throughout the years. 

Now, back to the actuaries. Believe it or not, these very smart people could identify with all the statistics above. They were modest, conscientious, curious, introverted achievers. Knowing this was the crucial first step. They had to see that it was possible for people like them to succeed. 

That's how we all are. Yet all too often we make assumptions that limit our success. Perhaps more data would help!


Source: "Seven Personality Traits of Top Salespeople," Steve W. Martin, Harvard Business Review, https://hbr.org/2011/06/the-seven-personality-traits-o


After a successful career in the sales world, writing five books, and speaking internationally, Jill is now tackling an even bigger challenge. She's focused on bringing the "millions in the middle" together to solve some of the biggest issues facing our country and the world. Jill truly believes so much more is possible if we can work together.